Disputed invoice: what to do when a customer won't pay

A customer disputes your invoice and won't pay? How to test the dispute, handle part payment, meet pre-action rules and decide when to issue a claim.

General information about UK law, written for businesses owed money. Not legal advice.

Published 7 November 2026

When a customer disputes an invoice and will not pay, the first step is to find out, in writing, exactly what is disputed and why. A genuine dispute about the work or the amount is settled by negotiation, mediation or, failing that, a court claim. A vague complaint raised only after you chased payment may be a delay tactic, and you can press on with the usual recovery steps while keeping a clear record.

This guide covers the law in England and Wales. Northern Ireland and other parts of the UK have their own rules.

1. Is it a real dispute, or a reason not to pay yet?

Most disputes fall somewhere between two ends.

At one end is a specific complaint raised promptly: the goods arrived damaged, part of the order was missing, the work was not finished, the price is not what was quoted. It names the problem, it came early, and it can be checked.

At the other end is a complaint that appears only when you ask for payment, after weeks of silence or of promises to pay. It is vague ("we're not happy with it"), it changes each time you ask, or it is used to hold back the whole invoice when the problem, if there is one, is small.

The signs worth noting are:

  • when the complaint was first raised, compared with when the goods or work were delivered;
  • whether the customer used the goods or the work after complaining;
  • whether they had already promised to pay, or paid earlier invoices for the same thing;
  • whether the complaint is specific enough to test.

None of these settles the matter on its own, but together they help you decide how firmly to respond.

2. What should you ask the customer to put in writing?

Ask the customer to set out the dispute in writing. Keep the request short and neutral:

  • which invoice, and which lines on it, are disputed;
  • what exactly is said to be wrong;
  • what the customer says the right figure is;
  • any evidence they rely on, such as photographs or reports;
  • confirmation that the rest of the invoice is accepted.

This is not only good practice. The court's Practice Direction on Pre-Action Conduct expects a defendant who does not accept a claim to say why, to identify which facts and which parts of the claim are disputed, and to say whether they have a counterclaim. A customer who will not do that has not engaged with the process the court expects.

Reply to each point in writing too. Phone calls are useful for settling things, but follow every call with a short email recording what was said.

3. What do your contract, terms and delivery records show?

Before you answer the complaint, go back to the paperwork:

  • The contract or order. What was agreed: the specification, the quantity, the price, the payment date.
  • Your terms of business. Were they sent before the contract was made, and accepted? Look for any clause on how and when complaints must be raised, on inspection of goods, and on payment terms.
  • Proof of delivery or completion. Signed delivery notes, courier records, timesheets, sign-off emails, photographs of finished work.
  • The customer's own messages. Anything thanking you, confirming receipt, or promising payment before the complaint appeared.

Be honest with yourself about what you find. If the complaint has substance, it is usually cheaper to deal with it now than to argue about it later in front of a judge. If your records answer it, set them out to the customer and ask for payment by a fixed date.

4. What if only part of the invoice is disputed?

A common pattern is a complaint about one item used to withhold payment for the whole invoice. Ask the customer to pay the part they accept now, and deal with the rest separately.

If you agree that part of the bill is wrong, issue a credit note for that part rather than amending or reissuing the invoice. It keeps your records and your VAT accounts straight and leaves a clear figure that is still owed. If you are offering a reduction only to settle the dispute, say in writing that it is an offer to settle and not an admission.

If the customer refuses to pay even the undisputed part, that is itself a sign that the dispute may be a reason not to pay. You can pursue that part on its own.

Where the court process starts, the government's guidance on responding to a court claim shows that a defendant can pay the full amount, offer to pay a different amount, or defend the claim. A part-disputed invoice often ends with the first two.

5. What do the courts expect before anyone sues?

The court expects both sides to try to settle first. The Practice Direction on Pre-Action Conduct applies where no specific pre-action protocol does. Where it applies, it says the steps will usually include the claimant writing with concise details of the claim, the defendant replying within a reasonable time (14 days in a straightforward case), and both sides disclosing key documents.

It also says litigation should be a last resort. Parties should consider negotiation or another form of alternative dispute resolution, such as mediation. If a claim is issued, the court may require evidence that this was considered, and an unreasonable refusal to take part may lead to an order to pay costs. Before issuing, the parties should take stock and, at the least, try to narrow the issues.

If the customer is a sole trader, the Pre-Action Protocol for Debt Claims applies instead. It says that where any aspect of the debt is disputed, the parties should exchange enough information and documents to understand each other's position, and should consider alternative dispute resolution.

Under Part 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, managing a case includes ordering or encouraging the parties to use alternative dispute resolution, and Part 3 gives the court power to order the parties to engage in it. Our guide to the letter before action covers what that first letter should say.

6. Can you use a statutory demand or a winding-up petition?

This is where a genuine dispute matters most. A statutory demand and a winding-up petition are insolvency steps. They are built for a debt the debtor cannot or will not pay, not for deciding whether the debt is owed at all.

The official sources point the same way:

So if the customer has a real, specific dispute, an insolvency route invites a challenge on exactly that point. The usual way to resolve a disputed debt is a claim, where the court decides what is owed. Once you have a judgment, the dispute has been decided. Our guide to the statutory demand explains when that route is the right one.

7. When is it time to issue a claim?

Issue a claim when you have asked for the dispute in writing, answered it with your evidence, offered a sensible way to settle, and the customer still will not pay what you say is due.

Some points to weigh:

  • Value and track. The amount affects which track the claim is allocated to and what costs can be recovered. Our guide to the small claims and fast track explains the difference.
  • Mediation. The government's guidance on mediation says that for claims of £10,000 or less, you will be told you must attend mediation organised by the court. It is free, lasts up to an hour, and an agreement reached there is legally binding.
  • Time. Under section 5 of the Limitation Act 1980, a claim founded on a simple contract cannot be brought more than six years after the cause of action accrued. Keep an eye on that date while a dispute runs on.

8. What records should you keep?

From the first complaint, keep everything in one file:

  • the contract, order and terms, and evidence they were sent and accepted;
  • the invoice, any credit notes, and a running statement of what is paid and what is still owed;
  • delivery and completion evidence;
  • every complaint, in the customer's own words, with its date;
  • your replies, and notes of every call;
  • any offer to settle, and the reply.

A dated, complete file is what lets you show the court that you explained your position, tried to settle, and acted reasonably. It is also what lets someone else pick up the matter quickly if you hand it over.

9. When to pass it on

You can manage a disputed invoice yourself. Many businesses hand it over when:

  • the customer will not say in writing what is disputed;
  • the dispute is about quality or specification and needs careful handling;
  • the customer is refusing even the undisputed part;
  • the amount is large enough that a mistake would be costly;
  • you are unsure whether a claim or an insolvency step is the right route;
  • the limitation deadline is getting close.

If a customer is disputing an invoice and you want a view on what to do next, tell us about the debt.

This guide is general information about the law in England and Wales as it stood when it was written. It is not legal advice, and it does not take account of your circumstances. For advice on a particular case, speak to a solicitor.

Owed money by another business?

A first conversation is confidential and without obligation. We will tell you plainly whether the debt is recoverable and how we would go about it.